402
TOPIC1876287010064133194229286
2.218428701005982
PHILOSOPHY2289287010061133168223292343413475546607
OF2919287010069124
THE3066287010064136193
ANCIENT3281287010065134190226283351415
WORLD3717287010096165232287359
8029178014010860120
Eleatic567596012886123185246284322384
problems990596012870123193261299361461514
of1539596012876113
the1686596012845113175
One19015960128101170231
and2166596012876146214
the2415596012844114176
Many26305960128117186254316
and2979596012868137207
ofmotion322059601287612233825960128101170208245315383
:3765596012839
objects3839596012875144182243304342396
could4269596012868137206244313
be4616596012876138
split4788596012860130167205243
into5065596012845114152221
a5321596012866
finite56783901284785154193230292
number893839012890158267333395441
of1368839012890136
particles1538839012890152198236273335372434488
and2059839012882151220
reassembled,2313839012867128189243296357466532571632701736
while30838390128121189228266328
the3444839012859128190
void3667839012890158197265
allowed3967839012882120157225326387456
for4457839012867136182
motion.46938390128109176214253323391425
The51528390128106174235
pattern5671080012870132170208270316384
of9851080012876122
the11411080012843113175
Eleatic13551080012886123185246283322383
Being17771080012893154192262332
was214910800128101162214
preserved23971080012876122184236298343412474542
in29731080012844113
the31211080012845113175
atoms33301080012868106174283334
–36981080012876
indivisible38091080012845114184221291328382419489527589
and44321080012868136206
imperishable46721080012843152219281326364418488550619656718
–5671321012870
but6721321012874143181
Many89113210128125186255324
replaced12481321012851112181219281342404472
the17541321012842112174
One.196613210128101170232266
The22691321012886155215
introduction25181321012843112150197264334402464501539609677
of32301321012873119
the33831321012844112174
voidmade35961321012862130169237387213210128109168237299
reality42051321012851112173211250287357
pluralistic45941321012874113182229290328365419456495556
and51841321012867135204
dynamic,5671563012870140207269378414475509
finally1111156301284583153215253291361
reconciling15041563012845106168237306368406444482551620
Eleatic21571563012885123184246283322384
logic25751563012836106175213274
with288115630128101138177246
the31621563012837107168
evidence33631563012861130169237299368430491
of38861563012871117
the40371563012836105166
senses.42371563012853115184237299352387
Their9211805012886154216254300
doctrine12561805012870140201238284322392452
became17431805012870132193254362422
the21991805012840110171
first2404180501284886132186224
conception26631805012863130200262323391429466536606
of33031805012871116
reality34531805012848109170208247285355
where384118050128101169231277338
unity42141805012870139178216286
was453318050128101162215
seen47831805012855117178247
not50651805012871140179
in52781805012840108
a5672046012862
single6632046012879117187255293355
principle10522046012893139177245307345413452514
but16002046012892162199
in18332046012863133
the20002046012862131193
homogeneity22272046012892162271337407469538600638675744
of30052046012893140
the31792046012862132194
elements.34072046012886122184292351420458512547
The398720460128110178240
motion426120460128134200239277347417
of47122046012893139
atoms48852046012886124192301352
is52712046012863117
strictly567228701285593147184246284321383
deterministic9852287012870132170231285386423491530582621658720
;17032287012839
there17772287012839109171216278
is2089228701283993
no22162287012872140
freedom2391228701284894155216284354463
in28852287012841111
nature.30302287012872134172240287348382
Later,34472287012886147185246292326
Epicurus38102287012886154191253322376445499
allowed43432287012865101140208309369438
that48162287012840109171208
atoms50582287012865103171280329
could5672529012862131201240308
spontaneously9092529012854122192260298360429490559627681720789
deviate17292529012870132201239300338400
(21632529012845
clinamen22062529012862100137207277378438506
)27112529012847
from2792252901284591160267
their30922529012837107169207253
path.33772529012870132170240274
The9212771012886154216
idea11712771012847117178240
of14452771012878124
the16032771012847117178
atom18152771012871107177286
proved21322771012879126195264325394
to25612771012847115
be27112771012878140
one28852771012878148209
of31282771012877123
the32942771012839107169
most350527710128102170224262
productive38012771012878131201269339400437476537598
metaphors444227710128102162200270340408478530584
in50612771012847116
the52112771012847117179
history5673012012870109163200270316385
of9843012012890136
thought.11543012012859129197267335405443478
It16653012012867104
underpins18023012012890160230290336405443512566
not24023012012889159196
only26333012012890158197266
classical29313012012883121182236290327389450488
physics34533012012889159229280319381434
but39223012012889158197
also41533012012882119173243
many445130120128109168237307
social47903012012875145206244306344
and51683012012883151220
political5673254012870140178216254291353414452
theories10543254012837107169236283320382434
of15233254012870116
the16733254012838107168
Modern187532540128125193263325370438
era,23483254012862107168202
which258432540128101169208270338
view29553254012870108170270
society32583254012855123185223285321391
as36813254012862116
an38313254012862131
aggregate39973254012862131199246307376438476536
of45673254012870116
independent47173254012838107176237306368436506567635672
individual5673495012839109178216285322392460522560
–11623495012879
«atoms».12753495012880140178247355406476511
Western183034950128132192245284345391460
civilization23253495012871109178217254293354416454491560629
itself2988349501284786140202238284
is33063495012849103
largely34433495012847109155224285322392
built38673495012879149187226264
upon41663495012878148217286
the44863495012848117178
metaphor470834950128109168205267336406476522
of52643495012879125
the5673737012839109170
atom.771373701286199167276309
All111237370128101138177
particulars13223737012870132178215254316385423484529583
–19383737012870
in20423737012838108
life,2184373701283875121182216
science,24343737012853115152214283344405439
and29073737012860129199
art31413737012860106144
–33183737012870
are34233737012860106167
atoms.3624373701286199167276327361
The9213978012878147209
Sophistswere11643978012870138208276315367406460165639780128101162208269
itinerant1959397801283977114184244290351420459
teachers2452397801283899161222291353398450
of29353978012871117
wisdom308639780128101138192261329438
who,355639780128101169239274
for38633978012847116162
a40603978012862
fee,41553978012847108169203
instructed43913978012838108160198244313375412474542
citizens4969397801286298137175236297366420
in5674220012839109
the7104220012863132194
skills9384220012878148185224262315
most128842200128133200254293
in16154220012864132
demand17804220012895157265324393463
in22774220012864134
democratic24454220012894156264330392438499538576638
Athens:311742200128126164232294363416454
the36064220012863133194
art38344220012887133170
of40384220012895140
dispute42124220012895133186256324363424
(46704220012872
eristic47414219012862115153207244283345
)50844220012847
and51634220012888157225
persuasive5674461012870132178231301363415453522583
speech11844461012857125187248309379
(15974461012849
rhetoric16434461012855124185223292346384445
).2087446101284781
Their22034461012886154216254300
main253944610128109168206276
task28494461012841103156226
was311244610128101162215
not33624461012872140179
natural35754461012872134171240287348384
philosophy39944461012872140179216286340408478546616
but46444461012870140178
preparing48574461012872118179248310356393462531
a5674702012862
person6634702012872134180233302371
for10694702012849116163
success12664702012856125186248309362415
in17164702012841109
public18604702012872140210247285347
and22414702012864132202
political24774702012871141178217254292354415453
life.2963470201284079125186220
To32194702012885154
this34074702012841110148201
end,36424702012865134202237
the39124702012841111171
Sophists41184702012878147217286324378415469
taught46214702012840102171239309346
how50024702012872140241
to52764702012841110
«think5674945012870107177216285354
and9554945012875144213
speak12024945012868137199260328
correctly»,15654945012875144190234296357395433503570603
analyze22034945012875144206244314373434
arguments,26714945012875121190260369428498536590624
avoid33294945012875144214252321
logical36844945012852122190229290350388
fallacies,41074945012858119157196257319356418470505
and46464945012875144213
structure48944945012867105151220282318388434494
one's5675186012870140202226279
speech8815186012855125186248308377
effectively.12925186012864110156217278315353422483520590622
In19475186012849118
doing21005186012872142180250318
so,24535186012856125159
they26465186012841109171240
contributed29185186012864135204243289325395463502564632
to35845186012841109
the37285186012841109171
development39345186012870132201263299369439547606675713
of46825186012872118
logic,48345186012840110178217278312
laid51805186012841103139208
the5675427012839109170
foundations7715427012895163232301370432469507576645698
of150354270128117163
rhetoric17005427012895162224262332378414476
as221054270128110162
a240754270128110
science,255054270128102164200262331393454487
and307054270128110179249
made335254270128157216285347
a373354270128110
huge387754270128117187255317
contribution422754270128110179248286332370438508545583652721
to49825427012886156
the51715427012887155217
emergence5675668012862172230276345407476538599
of11985668012871117
thehumanities1349566801283710716915495668012870139239308377416453492553606
.21545668012835
The9215911012886153214
Sophists116759110128119186255323360413449502
used170259110128110162223291
sophisms20665910012855122190259296349448500
–259859110128111
clever274159110128103140200267327372
tricks31465911012879124160220288340
and352059110128102170238
pseudo-logical379159110128110163223290358427473510577645682743802838
devices466459110128110171239276336396448
that51455911012879147208244
allowed567615201286299136205304363431
one10326152012870138198
to12636152012839107
win140261520128102138206
an16416152012863130
argument18036152012863107174243352409477514
even23506152012863130191259
if2642615201283984
truth2758615201283984152189256
was304761520128102161213
not32936152012870139176
on35026152012870137
their36726152012839107168205250
side.3954615201285591159219251
For42376152012879146191
them,44616152012839107167275307
to48006152012839107
«prove»49426152012870137182250318379447
often5676393012870115152212280
meant88063930128140198259327364
not127763930128101170207
to15176393012869137
find16886393012877113181249
objective197163930128101168205264324361398466527
truth25316393012869114182219286
but285163930128101168205
to30896393012870139
persuade326163930128100160205257325386453514
the38086393012868137197
audience.40386393012893160228265326394454514547
The461763930128117184245
Sophists489463930128109177245314351402439491
believed5676635012870131167205265333393461
that10606635012868136197233
absolute13256635012891159212279316384422481
(objective,18396635012875143212249309368405442511571604
universally24756635012899167204272332376429489525562630
valid)31366635012899159196233302346
truth35156635012868112180217285
does38336635012898166226278
not41456635012897165203
exist.43816635012891157194247284318
Knowledge473166350128130197266365401462529597657
depends5676877012870131199259327395448
on10476877012870138
circumstances1219687701286298143203271378428465526594654714766
and20196877012862130198
an22506877012863130
individual's24136877012838106175212279316385452512549571623
point30696877012871139176244282
of33836877012870114
view.35306877012870107168267299
The38616877012886153214
classical4107687701286399160212265302362422459
formulation45996877012847114159266332369429466503572640
of52726877012870115
this5677118012839107145197
idea7977118012837105166226
is1056711801283689
the11787118012836105165
thesis13767118012836105165217255306
ofProtagoras1714711801287011418597118012886137206243311380447500568621
:24777118012839
«25487118012870
Man261571180128117184253
is2901711801283789
the30227118012838106166
measure322071180128101160228281348401461
of37127118012870107
all38507118012870107144
things40267118012838106143210279332
».43577118012870102
Truth44907118012886130198235303
is4826711801283891
relative;49497118012845105142202239276344405440
truth567735901283984152189257
is858735901283689
created9777359012863107167227264324392
by14007359012870138
each15687359012862122182251
individual18527359012837105173211279315383452512549
or24327359012870115
community.25777359012862130237343411479516554622653
This32617359012885153190243
view35347359012871108168267
is3833735901283790
called39567359012861121157194255323
relativism43107359012855115152220257295355392443543
.48507359012835