416
TOPIC162129508966144205244315
1.19612950895176
PHILOSOPHY206329508960138177243321376454515593665
AS275329508972129
A290629508972
CULTURAL300429508972143210277349421492560
PHENOMENON358929508961139205277354449517589666739
1729178014010860120
think567769012839110148219288
that891769012860130193230
the1157769012860130193
sort1385769012876145192231
of1652769012891137
philosophy1823769012892162202240310365435504575646
I2502769012868
believe2605769012891154193233295364426
in3066769012860131
is3233769012860114
useful3382769012892147209255324364
in3781769012861130
this3947769012860130169223
way,42057690128122184255289
that4529769012860130193232
it479776901286099
enables4959769012862131202272310373428
people5671010012870133202273311374
to9761010012858127
act11391010012889151190
with136410100128113151190260
vigour16591010012881120190261330384
when207910100128112182245314
they're24291010012858127190252282336399
not28631010012888157197
absolutely30951010012888159213282322391431493532594
certain37251010012881142197235306344418
that41781010012858128198237
that44511010012856127197236
is47231010012856111
the48701010012856127190
right50951010012872112181251289
action5671253012870133172210280351
.9181253012835
I9881253012846
think10691253012840110148219289
nobody13931253012870141210280351412
should18411253012855125195265303374
be22511253012870132
certain24171253012863126179219288328397
of28501253012870109
anything29941253012871141203242312350421491
.34881253012835
If3558125301284794
you're36871253012871140210236281344
certain,40661253012863124171210273311381417
you're45181253012871139210235281343
certainly48961253012864126171211273311381420490
wrong,56714940128101148218289358394
because9961494012870133195258327382444
nothing14751494012872142180251289359430
deserves19401494012871134187250297366429482
certainty.24581494012864126172211274312381421491525
And301914940128102171242
so32971494012855124
one34631494012870140203
ought37001494012872141212282320
always40561494012871110203273336390
to44811494012841111
hold46271494012871141180250
all49121494012871111149
one's50971494012871141204233288
beliefs5671735012870133172210273311366
with9721735012894133171241
a12481735012875
certain13581735012866128183221291331400
element17931735012866105168270331400440
of22681735012874112
doubt24161735012874144214284323
.27411735012835
And281517350128102171241
one30911735012875145207
ought33331735012874144214284322
to36911735012843114
be38411735012873136
able40121735012866136174236
to42831735012843113
act44311735012867129167
vigorously46341735012874113183253299370439494533603
in52711735012843114
spite5671977012855125164203265
of8671977012881128
the10301977012848118181
doubt.12461977012880150220290329364
After165719770128101147186249296
all,19881977012873111150186
this22091977012848118157211
is24551977012850104
what260519770128101171234272
a29121977012873
general30191977012880143213275322384422
does34771977012880150213266
when378919770128101171234303
he's41271977012881143168223
planning43851977012881119182251322360430500
a49211977012871
battle.50281977012880143181220259322355
He56722190128101163
doesn't7652219012875145208262332358396
quite11962219012875144183222285
know15162219012874144214315
what187022190128101171233272
the21782219012843113176
enemy23892219012867137198308377
will280522190128101140180220
do,30602219012874144180
but32752219012874144182
if3493221901284390
he's36182219012875137162217
a38702219012867
good39722219012875144214284
general,42922219012873136205268315377415451
he47782219012874137
guesses49502219012874144207260314377431
right.567246001284786156226265300
If9022460012864111
he's10482460012887149175228
a13122460012879
bad14272460012886149218
general,16812460012886148218281328390428464
he21802460012886149
guesses23642460012886156219273328390444
wrong.284324600128119164234305375410
But328824600128111180219
one35422460012891161224
has,38002460012888151204240
in40752460012855125
practical42352460012887134196259297336398460499
life,4769246001285695142204239
to50432460012856126
act52042460012880142180
upon5672702012870141210280
probabilities.8832702012870117186256318389427465505543583645699735
And165227020128102171242
what193027020128101170232271
I22372702012846
should23182702012853124194263303372
look27262702012839108179248
to30092702012839109
philosophy31542702012870140178217287341412481552623
to38102702012839109
do39532702012871141
is4130270201283791
to42572702012839108
encourage44012702012862132194264333381443512575
people50112702012870132202271310373
to5672943012839110
act7122943012863123162
with91029430128101140178249
vigour,11932943012870108179249318365400
without162829430128101140178249319388428
complete20912943012863131241309348411450513
certainty.26392943012862123170209271310379419489523
Interviewer:9213187012655131175235295363400461559621681726
Yes,167931850128101161213246
but19583185012870138175
now,21663185012871139238270
how24693185012870138238
about27393185012863131199267305
this30773185012839107144197
business,33063185012870138191228297357408461494
though,38333185012839107175244311379413
of42783185012870115
making442631850128110168236273342410
people48693185012871131199266303364
so52653185012855123
uncertain5673426012870139199259303340401437506
about11033426012863131199267303
things14403426012836104142210277330
they18023426012837105165235
believe20653426012870130167204265333393
and24883426012863130199
have27173426012871131199259
faith30093426012844104141178246
in,32893426012836104138
doesn't34563426012871139199252320344380
that38693426012837105166202
rather41043426012845104141210270314
disturb44483426012871108161198266311379
them?48603426012837105165272330
Russell:92136700126101179233289351389429475
Well,144736680128133193232272307
it1789366801285493
does19173668012886156219272
for22253668012863132179
a24393668012878
time,2552366801285694204264299
of28863668012886133
course.30543668012879148219265319381416
And350636680128117187256
I37983668012862
think38953668012854125163234303
a42343668012877
certain43473668012878141186224287326396
amount47783668012878187255325396435
of52483668012887133
disturbance5673909012870110164203273320389452521584646
is1248390901284297
an13813909012865136
essential15523909012867121175237306346384447485
part20733909012874136183222
of23303909012874121
mental249039090128110170240279342380
training.2906390901284390151190261299369440475
But34203909012894163201
if3657390901284390
they37833909012842111174244
have40613909012874137207270
any43663909012867136207
knowledge46063909012875145216318355418487557620
of52613909012874120
science,5674150012855117156218288351412448
they10504150012842112174245
get13284150012873136174
a15384150012865
ballast16374150012872135173212275329367
which204341500128101171209272341
enables24204150012865134197266305367422
them28774150012842112173284
to31934150012843113
avoid33424150012864134204242313
being36904150012873135174243314
completely40394150012865134243311350413452515554624
upset46974150012873144198260298
by50314150012872143
the52074150012842113176
doubts5674393012870141210280320374
that9764393012839108171209
they12214393012839108171241
ought14954393012870141211281320
to18504393012839108
feel.19944393012847109171209245
Interviewer:9214636012655133180242305374412475575638700747
What170346340128133201264303
do20404634012870140
you22154634012870138209
think24604634012839108147217288
is2783463401283893
the29114634012838107170
future31164634012847117155225272334
of34844634012870117
philosophy?36374634012870139179217287342411481552622683
Russell:92148770126101179233289351389429475
I14314875012880
don't154648750128102172243268306
think18884875012871140180249319
philosophy224348750128102172211249320374445514584655
can29314875012895158228
in31954875012871141
the33714875012872142204
future36104875012880150188259306367
have401248750128102165235297
anything43444875012896165234272342382452522
like49024875012871110180242
the51784875012873142205
importance5675116012839149216287334373436505568630
that12335116012847118180219
it1487511601284787
had16095116012879141210
either18555116012871110149219281328
to22185116012848118
the23725116012847117179
Greeks259551160128102148210273343397
or30285116012879126
in31895116012847118
the33425116012847117180
Middle356651160128125163233303341404
Ages.401551160128101171233288324
I43745116012855
think44645116012847117157226297
the48095116012839109171
rise50165116012863102156219
of52705116012878116
science5675358012855117156218288351412
inevitably10155358012839108171233271310380450489552
diminishes16015358012870108209248318357412481544598
the22345358012839108171
importance24405358012839141209280334373443513576638
of31125358012870109
philosophy32555358012870141180219289343413483553615
.38735359012835
Interviewer:9215602012655133180242305374412475575638700747
Well,166956000128133193232272307
would201156000128101169240279348
you23955600012870138209
summarize26395600012855125235343403450489552614
the32885600012839108171
value34945600012870132171241303
of38305600012870117
philosophy39855600012870140179218287342412482552614
?45995600012862
Russell:92158430126101179233289351389429475
First,14315841012889128174228267302
because,17685841012881143205267336390453488
as22915841012873126
I24535841012857
say,25455841012864127197230
it2810584101285089
keeps29475841012862124186256310
you32935841012871141211
realizing35405841012865126197235275329367438508
that40845841012848119188227
there43465841012850119182236298
are46795841012880135198
very49115841012872135188251
big51975841012880119189
and5676082012870141210
very8136082012870133186249
important10976082012847149217288342380451521560
questions16936082012877146209264302340411481535
that22636082012847117188226
science25256082012862125163226295357420
at29806082012877116
any31326082012877148209
rate33766082012863133172235
at36466082012877117
present37986082012877132195248311380419
can't42526082012870141210241280
deal45676082012877140209249
with48596082012894131171241
,51076083012835
and51776083012870139210
that5676325012839110172210
a8136325012875
scientific9226325012867130168231300338378425463526
attitude14836325012875113151191231302371434
by19526325012882152
itself2138632501285291146208247294
is24666325012852106
not26076325012882153191
adequate.28346325012875144206276346408447509544
And342863250128102171241
the37046325012852122185
second39236325012867130191261331401
thing43596325012852121161231300
it4695632501285190
does48206325012882152215269
is5138632501283993
to52676325012850120
make56765660128101171234296
people8986566012886148218288327389
a13226566012886
little1443656601285594132171210273
more176565660128102171226289
modest208965660128118186256319373412
intellectually25366566012855125164226264304366428466536606646684747
and33206566012879149219
aware35746566012879180242288350
that39606566012854125187225
a42206566012879
great43346566012886133195257296
many468165660128109169239310
things50246566012856126166237306361
which56768070128101171210273342
have9456807012878140210273
been12536807012877140202271
thought15606807012846116186255326396434
certain20306807012870132179217280319389
turned24546807012846117164233296365
out28546807012878148187
to30776807012846116
be32296807012877140
untrue,34046807012877147186233302365400
and38396807012870139210
that40846807012846116178217
there's43376807012846115178225287313366
no47396807012878147
shortcut49226807012863132202249288350420458
to5677049012839110
knowledge,7127049012894165234336374437506576639674
and14217049012887157227
that16837049012864134196235
the19797048012839110171
understanding21867048012895164235297351405445514584655693763832
of30547048012895133
the32237048012864133196
world345470480128119189243282352
,38087049012835
which387870490128126196234297366
to42797049012864134
my444870490128134203
mind468670490128135172242313
is50347049012864119
the52167048012839109171
underlying5677291012870141210273327366428467537607
purpose12107291012874144199269338393455
that17017291012845114177216
every19537291012866137198245315
philosopher23027291012876146186224295349418489559622668
should30047291012860131201270310379
have,34197291012876138208270305
The37647291012886156218
death40177291012875138199238312
is4364729101284498
a44977291012868
very46007291012876138185255
long48887291012845115186256
and51797291012868137207
difficult5677532012870110157202241304373412451
business,10527532012870141195235304367420474510
about15977532012862132202272311
which194375320128102171210272341
we232075320128101163
ought25187532012870139210280319
not28717532012870140179
to30867532012837108
be32287532012870133
dogmatic.33957532012870140210320380419458521556