73
?, -&0%( &?0(,(,&(
( <0.01),
,
,
,
( <0.001). &
' !,(,&&
,10 $ &)( &(0
,, - &),& ?, -(,&. &,/($',%. %*(,$&
'%')%+,&+ )$ ,(. %/%,) 0(H/# 1-%. & 2-%. &''2(/%! )(2>'$&0& )%-$ 0&
%2#-(,% ') )&')&-('$& ?, -&0%( &?0(,(,&(
( <0.01),
,
,
,
( <0.001).
, 2&? ,10 $ &)( &(0
,, - &),& ?, -(,&. &,/($',%. %*(,$&
'%')%+,&+ )$ ,(. %/%,) 0(H/# 2-%. & 3-(. &''2(/%! )(2>'$&0& )%-$ 0&
') )&')&-('$& ?, -&0%( &?0(,(,&(
( <0.01) & ?, -(,&+ &,/($'
( <0.01), ! ' !,(,&& '% ?, -(,&+0& !% !)% %. &''2(/%! )(2>'$%. )%-$(
!1+!&2% ') )&')&-('$& ,( ?, -&0%( &?0(,(,&( ?, -(,&. &,/($'%! ! ) ()>(.
&''2(/%! )(2>'$%. )%-$(
=0.76,
=0.623,
=0.634 ( >0.05).
, -(,&( $%'),%A% %$ ? )(2+ !% ! (0+ ( !&-,%A% %@'2(/%! ,&+ '%') !2+2%
65.69 ± 15.29 @ 22 & ! /&, 0&$( 2(-(,&+ ,( 0(,+2%'>.
('0%) + , )%, -)% %$ ? )(2& %/%,) 2>,%A% &,/($' ''(2 !
) (" &''2(/%! )(2>'$&" )%-$ ", '%A2 ',% $ &)( &O
#'$ 2 - %22&'
') )&')&-('$& ?, -&0% ,( ?2&- O)'+ ( >0.05), , 2&? $ &)( &(0
&2$%$'%, 0(H/# 1-%. & 2-%. &''2(/%! )(2>'$&0& )%-$ 0&, (-( (? 14 /,(.
%) , - 2 2(-(,&+), & 0(H/# 2-%. & 3-(. &''2(/%! )(2>'$&0& )%-$ 0&, (-( (?
90 /,(. %) , - 2 2(-(,&+), ?2&-&+ %/%,) 2>,%A% &,/($'
''(2
+!2+O)'+ ') )&')&-('$& ?, -&010& ( <0,05). ) )&')&-('$& ,(?, -&010&
+!2+O)'+ ?2&-&+ ?, -(,&. $%'),%A% %$ ? )(2+, A2#@&,1 %/%,) 2>,1"
$ 0 ,%! & (*(''&& /(',1 , !'(" U) " 2(-(,&+ ( >0.05).
?2&-&+
?, -(,&. %$ ? )(2+, " $)( &?#OF(A% )%2%A&-('$#O %/!&H,%')> ?#@%!
0(H/# ( !%. & ) ()>(. &''2(/%! )(2>'$&0& )%-$ 0&, '%A2 ',% $ &)( &O
#'$ 2 - %22&' , +!2+O)'+ ') )&')&-('$& ,(?, -&010& ( >0.05)
3.3. 2&,&-('$ + " $)( &')&$ '%')%+,&+ %2%')& ) # 2&* ' " %,&-('$&0
A(,( 2&?%! ,,10 %/%,)&)%0 )+H(2%. ')( (,& )+H(')&
& ( !&-,%0 %'0%) (, '@% ( , 0,(? ? @%2(! ,&+, !1+',(,&&
H 2%@ (1-+ &''2(/%! )(2>'$ + )%-$ )
*&(,)%! '
(/\+!2+2&