Упрощенная HTML-версия
9
"#,9.6""8 III
1
6-8*(78*!8 #,8.E&*!) T.!'.#=!'#$ ! 98-#9+#D!*& *# !+# +!7(
?&.&5'8. '8*,8*=!! (p>0,05). "#,9.6""8 III
2
'#+(5# *!E8*!8 5#+!%8 '$& T.!'.#=!'#$ !-8+#
?&.&5'8. '8*,8*=!! (p>0,05), & 6-8*(78*!8 #,8.E&*!) 98-#9+#D!*& "# #'*#78*!F 5 9.6""8
.&$*8*!) D@+# 6E8 '&'! '!%8 5! ,# '#$8.*@- ! # '&$!+# 5% (
p<
0,05). "#,9.6""8 III
3
*&D+F,&+# ( '&'! '!%8 5! <*&%!-#8 *!E8*!8, 5&5 6.#$*) T.!'.#=!'#$, '&5 ! 98-#9+#D!*&:
17% ! 13% ##'$8' '$8**# "# #'*#78*!F 5 "#5&<&'8+)- <,#.#$@? D8.8-8**@? E8*G!*
(
p<
0,05). t'#' ;&5' '8- D#+88 !*'8.8 8*, %'# *!E8*!8 T.!'.#=!'#$ ! 98-#9+#D!*& 6
D8.8-8**@? ')E8+@- 98 '#<#- !-8+# #D.&'*6F 5#..8+)=!#**6F <&$! !-# '(
6$8+!%8*!8- 5#*=8*'.&=!! !#*#$ E8+8<& $ "+&<-8. t'# "#,'$8.E,&8' $@,$!*6'#8 *&-!
".8,"#+#E8*!8 #D T.!'.#=!'&.*#- ".#! ?#E,8*!! "#$@78**#9# 6.#$*) $ "+&<-8
@$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<&. .! +895#> ! .8,*8> '8"8*! ')E8 '! 98 '#<& *&D+F,&+& ( +!7(
+&D&) '8*,8*=!) 5 *!E8*!F # -#'!%8 5#> .8<! '8*'*# '! T.!'.#=!'#$. 8 '#< ')E8+#>
'8"8*!, *&".#'!$, #".#$#E,&+ ) <*&%!'8+(*@- *!E8*!8- .8<! '8*'*# '! T.!'.#=!'&.*#>
-8-D.&*@.
*&.678*!! #D-8*& E8+8<& ".! 98 '#<8 $!,8'8+( '$#$&+# ! !<-8*8*!8 5#*=8*'.&=!!
;8..!'!*&. &5 6 "&=!8*'#5 "#,9.6""@ III
1
89# 5#*=8*'.&=!) $#<.& '&+& *& 74,0% "#
#'*#78*!F 5 89# "#5&<&'8+)- ".! ;!<!#+#9!%8 5#> D8.8-8**# '!.
+) 98 '#<& .8,*8>
'8"8*! D@+# ?&.&5'8.*# 6$8+!%8*!8 5#*=8*'.&=!! ;8..!'!*& $ 2,1 .&<& "# #'*#78*!F 5
9.6""8 .&$*8*!). &5 !-&+(*&) 5#*=8*'.&=!) ;8..!'!*& *&D+F,&+& ( $ "#,9.6""8 III
3
, 9,8
89# #,8.E&*!8 6$8+!%!+# ( $ 3,4 .&<& "# #'*#78*!F 5 9.6""8 II, $ 2 .&<& $ .&$*8*!!
"#,9.6""#> III
1
! $ 1,6 .&<& #'*# !'8+(*# "#,9.6""@ III
2
.
8.#)'*#, 6$8+!%8*!8 5#*=8*'.&=!! ;8..!'!*& ".! 98 '#<8 )$+)+# ( 5#-"8* &'#.*#>
.8&5=!8>, *&".&$+8**#> *& *!E8*!8 =!'#'#5 !%8 5!? T;;85'#$ !#*#$ E8+8<&. ,*&5#, 8 +!
".! +895#> ! .8,*8> '8"8*! ')E8 '! 98 '#<& 6.#$8*( @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<& D@+ ,&E8 *!E8
"#5&<&'8+8> 9.6""@ .&$*8*!), '# ".! ')E8+#- 98 '#<8 -#G*# '! 5#-"8* &'#.*@?
$#<-#E*# '8> *8 ?$&'&+#, %'# #".#$#E,&+# ( .&<$!'!8- 9!"8.;8..8-!!.
<-8*8*!) "#5&<&'8+8> !*'8* !$*# '! ".#=8 #$ $#D#,*#-.&,!5&+(*#9# #5! +8*!) $
"+&<-8 ! *& T.!'.#=!'&? ".! 98 '#<&? +895#> ! .8,*8> '8"8*! ')E8 '! 5#..8+!.#$&+!
!<-8*8*!8- 5#*=8*'.&=!! @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<& $ 5.#$!. T'!? 9.6""&? *&D+F,&+& ( ".)-&)
5#..8+)=!#**&) <&$! !-# '( !+(*#> '8"8*! -8E,6 $8'# 6--#>, $ "@75#>, "#*'&**#>
$8'!-# '(F "+&<-@ ! 6.#$*8- @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<&.
.! 98 '#<8 ')E8+#> '8"8*! *8
6,&+# ( $@)$!'( 5#..8+)=!#**@? $)<8> -8E,6 <*&%8*!)-! ?8-!+F-!*8 =8*=!! "+&<-@ !
5#*=8*'.&=!8> E8+8<& $ @$#.#'58. ,*&5# $ T'#> 9.6""8 '&5E8 #'-8%&+& ( -&5 !-&+(*#
$@.&E8**&) ".)-&) 5#..8+)=!) -8E,6 6.#$*8- @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<& ! $8'# 6--#>
?8-!+F-!*8 =8*=!! T.!'.#=!'#$.
&D+!=& 3
/#
!!' / % "
/% % &% ! # !#
%' .
#
!# ! # $ '
0!
(
(
% !)
&.& .&$*!$&8-@? "#5&<&'8+8>
#,9.6""& III
1
(n=32)
#,9.6""& III
2
(n=18)
#,9.6""& III
3
(n=14)
$8'# 6--&
"+&<-@ –
5#*=8*'.&=!) @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<&
r=0,79
=0,011
r=0,76
=0,018
r=0,54
=0,016
"@75&
"+&<-@ – 5#*=8*'.&=!)
@$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<&
r=0,81
=0,041
r=0,88
=0,015
r=0,62
=0,033
"#*'&**&) $8'!-# '(
"+&<-@ –
5#*=8*'.&=!) @$#.#'#%*#9# E8+8<&
r=0,75
=0,032
r=0,77
=0,023
r=0,50
=0,042
$8'# 6--&
T.!'.#=!'#$ –
5#*=8*'.&=!) @$. E8+8<&
r=0,87
=0,001
r=0,91
=0,001
r=0,93
=0,001